Do we put cameras (also) in the classroom? 5 reasons why it might not be a good idea
by Get Stealth Chicago Stealth Security & Home Theatre Systems, IncDo we put cameras (also) in the
classroom? 5 reasons why it might not be a good idea
Is it a good idea to put cameras in all classes to monitor the
lessons?
Sometimes we go back to talking about cameras at school and,
specifically, cameras installed
right in the classrooms.
A law providing for the security camera installation in each class was about to enter into
force in 2019. The text had been approved by the Chamber, but was then stopped
the following year by the Senate.
"Camera yes - camera
no" was also a survey on the page of "beautiful proof". You have
participated en masse and with great enthusiasm, not limiting yourself to
voting, but sharing your opinion with passion.
I take this opportunity to thank you all, especially for the
civilization shown in supporting often conflicting ideas. It is difficult to
find such a heterogeneous community on Facebook, but also as committed.
The majority showed themselves
to be in favor, but I think the time has come to give you my opinion.
We must make a premise: there is already a law that provides for the
use of cameras at school. But the current legislation only allows them to
monitor the environments, prohibiting them in the classroom, subject to some
serious exceptions.
In practice, therefore, what we are discussing is whether it is
appropriate to put them in a corner of the class, perhaps on the ceiling, lit
and functioning, for the duration of the class hours, in a continuous and
ordinary manner.
Personally, unlike the majority, I am NOT in favor.
For at least 5 reasons.
1) First reason: there is no
real emergency.
Putting cameras in all classes is likely to be a useless answer to a need
created by a media effect. It does not seem appropriate to me to make laws -
which, always said incidentally, cost a lot of money - to respond to the
emotion rather than meet an actual need.
Put simply: bullying or abuse occurs at school, but it rarely takes on
truly worrying proportions.
The school is not a paradise, but in almost all schools the vast
majority of teachers know how to keep a class under control, even if they make
a big liver like that.
Last year, when there was talk of bullying the facts to ... some
friends asked me what was happening at school and they looked at me like a
veteran who had escaped the war in Afghanistan. This is because the fact that
the images of the bully that threatened the professor were repeated
continuously [fig.], Mobilizing the national emergency. But, in my opinion,
there was and there is no emergency, except in certain cases and certainly not
at a national level.
2) Security
Cameras system are an external surveillance element that interferes with
an educational purpose.
In practice: if there are no serious situations to monitor, putting
everyone under control is useless, if not useless.
On the contrary, the presence of cameras can become an element of
interference and disturbance, bringing into the classrooms discussions and
tensions that are external to the school.
Let's take a football example. Since using the VAR (Video assistant
referee) on the field, there neither is no less fouls and a better game for
this… nor has the endless discussions off the field been put an end.
But even if the VAR solves some problems in football, the difference
with the school is enormous. Educational work is not a sport and, above all, it
is not a show for which you pay the ticket. A school with cameras is just a
more controlled school, not a better educational place
3) The context.
The comparison with the VAR, for how much it will make someone's hair
stand on end, gives me the inspiration for another opposite reason: the cameras
offer images that must be interpreted but that, if they filter out, are
fragmented and out of context.
Let's take an example. Remember the famous video of the bully? In
particular, they shot two shots (which are still on the Internet), in one you
could see a boy who threatened a professor to put him six, in the other a boy
who rushed against him with his head down.
A lot was talked about and the prevailing judgment that was
circulating was that the professor didn't know how to do his job, because he
remained impassive without blinking an eye. Someone even wondered why he hadn't
reacted (and even turned some vignettes that imagined the professor giving up a
nice slap ...).
I think, on the contrary, that that teacher, who continued to do his
job while remaining in class and, above all, keeping calm - just that teacher -
would deserve a monument (how about, in parentheses, a monument to the teacher
"Unknown" who fights for the homeland every day, often forgotten as a
Japanese soldier still at war on the last Pacific island?).
The problem, in judging those images, is that they lent themselves to
fomenting spirits but they were all out of context. We didn't know anything
about that class. We didn't know anything about those kids and that
environment.
In that scene I saw, as a professor, a boy in evident social and
relational difficulty in front of a professor who reacts exactly how one should
react in such a situation: to stand still and keep the point without making a
turn.
4) The security cameras in the
classroom are aimed at people, not at an environment.
It is not like putting them at the entrance or in a corridor, or at
the entrance to the office or the professors' room. The cameras in the
classroom monitor the pupils, i.e. children and adolescents, and above all the
professors, i.e. workers while exercising their profession.
Here the matter becomes complicated, because the regulatory
complications that protect both the direct filming of minors and workers are
lost.
5) Finally: is it not more
sensible to invest more in education than in forms of control?
This means having not only better environments, but better teachers. I
know it is unpopular to say it, but if there is money for school, it must be
used to support more teachers who are already the real supervisors and
overseers of the class. If we don't want to pay them more - as it would be
right anyway, and now that I have said it, let me have it - then let's work
more teachers in classes with fewer students, in more manageable conditions, so
that they can better conduct the relationship with their students.
A good teacher is worth more than all the cameras in the world.
Let me know what you think in the comments.
And if you like my videos, don't forget to subscribe to the channel.
We will talk about school, religion, theology, culture and all that I am
passionate about and that I hope you are passionate about, even if you think
differently from me.
Related Post: Video
surveillance cameras and Privacy security system
Related Post: The
importance of a video surveillance system for your business
Related Post:
Outdoor
surveillance camera-best outdoor cameras of 2020
Related
Post- Mobile
Video Surveillance Cameras - Tips and Prices
Related
Post- Some
basic information for home surveillance camera
Sponsor Ads
Created on Dec 22nd 2019 05:26. Viewed 687 times.