Private Limited Company vs LLP in India, Best Business Structure for Foreigners

Looking to foray into India's diverse and dynamic market? Entering the Indian market is a strategic move for many global entrepreneurs and investors, as it offers a new opportunity to tap into a growing market. However, one of the first and most critical challenges you'll face is choosing the right business structure.

For foreigners, the debate primarily revolves around two most popular business structures: the Private Limited Company (PLC) and the Limited Liability Partnership (LLP). Both structures offer limited liability protection but differ significantly in terms of their operations, compliance obligations, and perception.

Delving into LLP vs Private Limited Company for foreign companies can help choose the structure that aligns well with your business goals in India.

Limited Liability Partnership (LLP)

An LLP is a desirable business structure combining features of a partnership and a company. It offers the flexibility of internal governance based on a mutual agreement while providing partners with limited liability protection.  

Key Advantages for Foreigners:  

• Lower & Easier Compliance: LLPs don't require a mandatory audit conduction unless the turnover exceeds ₹40 lakhs or the capital contribution exceeds ₹25 lakhs.

• Flexibility in Management: This structure is governed by an LLP Agreement that outlines partners' roles, profit sharing and responsibilities with great flexibility.

• Lower Registration Cost: LLP Incorporation cost is generally lower than a Private Limited Company in India.

Potential Drawbacks:

• Limited Access to Funding: LLPs find it harder to attract venture capital or private equity investments, as investors typically prefer the share-based structure of a company.

• Perception: It may be perceived as a less formal structure compared to a Private Limited Company, which can impact dealings with large corporations.

• Taxation: While the LLP itself is not taxed, the profits are distributed to partners and taxed in their hands. There is no option for dividend distribution tax benefits.

Private Limited Company (PLC)

A Private Limited Company is a separate legal entity, distinct from its owners (generally shareholders). It is the most preferred structure for businesses planning to scale higher and raise funds.

Key Advantages for Foreigners:

• Investor Confidence: A Pvt Ltd Company structure is considered the gold standard for attracting investment. The ability to issue shares and stock options makes it highly attractive to investors.

• Separate Legal Entity: The company's existence is independent of its shareholders. This provides strong brand credibility and perpetual succession irrespective of change in the lifespan of their directors.  

• Tax Benefits: This structure has easier access to tax benefits and deductions. As a result, it can avail several tax benefits and also enjoys a lower corporate tax rate

Potential Drawbacks

• Stringent & Higher Compliance: Private Limited companies are subject to stricter regulatory compliance. This includes mandatory audits regardless of turnover, annual filings with the Registrar of Companies (ROC), and more complex governance requirements.              

• Higher Costs: The registration process is more detailed, resulting in higher compliance costs compared to other business structures in India.

Private Limited Company vs LLP India: Key Factors for Foreigners  

​

Which One is Best for You?

Without comprehensively addressing a business requirement, it is not possible to suggest  the best business structure for foreigners in India. In fact, the best structure is not a one-size-fits-all approach. Choosing the right business structure depends on your business objectives and long-term goals.

Choose Private Limited Company if:

• You are looking forward to raising significant external funding from Angel Investors, Venture Capitalists, or private equity in the future.

• Your goal is to achieve high growth by rapidly scaling up your business.

• You can manage a lengthy compliance framework.  

On the other hand, you can choose an LLP if:

• Your business is professional services offering firms such as Consultants, Architects, Lawyers, etc.  

• You want operational flexibility and lower compliance requirements.

• You have no plans of raising high capital.

• You plan to start a small to medium-sized enterprise at a low cost.

Conclusion

For foreigners, both the Private Limited Company and the LLP act as a robust gateway to the Indian Market. A private limited company structure is best suited for the ambitious, high-scaling ventures seeking investment. On the other hand, an LLP is an excellent and efficient option for small to mid-sized professional services-driven businesses that require flexibility.

Before deciding the most suitable structure, it’s often advisable to consult a corporate legal expert/company that provides tailored business incorporation consultation tailored to your specific nationality, business activity, and financial projections. Making the right decision at the early stage will pave the path for a smooth and successful journey in one of the world's most dynamic economies.

Choose the best structure by consulting experts like Setindiabiz or such other renowned names.