What should you carry on a hiking trip - Backpack or Duffle Bag?

When you’re heading out on a hiking trip, the choice between a backpack and a duffle bag comes down to how you plan to carry and access your gear, the length and remoteness of your trip, and the terrain you’ll be covering. Here’s a breakdown to help you choose:

---

1. Backpacks

Best for: multi-day hikes, off-trail or uneven terrain, when you need hands-free mobility

Pros	Cons
Ergonomic Load Distribution – Padded shoulder straps, hip belt, and adjustable frame keep weight centered over your hips, reducing shoulder/back fatigue.	Organizational Complexity – Multiple compartments mean you need to think about where to stash each item.
Hands-free Mobility – Keeps your hands free for scrambling, using trekking poles, or balance on uneven ground.	Limited Top-Loading – While panel-loading packs exist, many require you to unpack to reach bottom items.
Hydration Compatibility – Most packs have reservoir sleeves and tube routing.	Weight Overhead – Even a well-fitted pack can feel heavy on shoulders on very long carries.
Compression Straps & External Carry – Good for strapping on sleeping pads, trekking poles, ice axes, or wet gear.

---

2. Duffle Bags

Best for: car-camping basecamps, short trail-to-camp carries, when you don’t need to scramble or use poles

Pros	Cons
Easy Packing & Access – One large compartment; everything is in view and easy to reach.	Poor Weight Distribution – No hip belt; you must carry at your side or over one shoulder, leading to fatigue.
Durability & Volume – Many duffels (especially expedition duffels) are weather-proof and offer huge capacity.	Awkward on Trail – Cannot carry hands-free; awkward on narrow or technical sections.
Simplicity – No adjustment needed; you just load it up and go.	Limited Hands-Free – You’re stuck dragging, carrying, or slinging it; not ideal for long carries.
	No Hydration Carry – No dedicated place for water reservoirs or quick-access pockets.

---

3. When to Choose Which

Scenario	Recommended Bag
Backpacking for multiple days on varied terrain	Backpack
Day hikes with minimal gear (snacks, water, light jacket)	Small day-pack backpack
Car-camping or trailhead-to-camp shuttles	Duffle bag (to move bulk gear in your vehicle)
Glacier or mountaineering trips requiring poles/axes	Technical backpack with ice-tool loops
Weekend trips where you’ll split gear between friends	Backpacks for each person; duffel for communal gear

---

4. Key Features to Look For

• Capacity:

  • Day-packs: 15–30 L

  • Overnight packs: 40–60 L

  • Expedition packs: 60 L+

  • Duffel bags: 40 L–100 L+

• Fit & Comfort (Backpacks):

  • Adjustable torso length

  • Padded hip belt with pockets

  • S-shaped shoulder straps

  • Ventilated back panel

• Access & Organization:

  • Top-loader vs panel-loader (backpacks)

  • External pockets vs single-compartment (duffels)

• Weather Resistance:

  • Rain covers or waterproof fabrics

  • Sealed seams (duffels)

---

Bottom Line

For most trail-based hiking—especially if you’re carrying more than just water and snacks—a dedicated backpack with waist-belt support and multiple carry options is almost always the better choice. Reserve a duffle bag for basecamp transfers, vehicle-to-trailhead shuttles, or situations where you don’t need to carry the bag on your back for long distances.

Happy hiking!