Fixing Data Discrepancies Between GA4 and Other Tools

If you're working with GA4 (Google Analytics 4) and comparing its data to other platforms—like marketing automation tools, CRM systems, or ad platforms—you’ve likely noticed discrepancies. Before you panic, it's important to understand that data discrepancies are common and often rooted in differences between how tools track, process, and report data.

Here’s a breakdown of why this happens and actionable steps to address and minimize those discrepancies.

Why Do Data Discrepancies Happen?

Tracking Methodology

GA4 primarily uses event-based tracking, while other platforms might rely on session-based or pixel-based tracking. This difference can lead to variation in metrics like sessions, users, and conversions.

Time Zone Settings

Mismatched time zones between GA4 and other tools can create inconsistencies in daily reporting metrics.

Attribution Models

Different platforms use different attribution models. For example, GA4 defaults to a data-driven attribution model, while tools like Facebook Ads Manager often use last-click or first-click attribution.

Data Sampling

Some tools apply sampling to their data sets, especially with large volumes of data. GA4 may sample reports if your dataset exceeds its thresholds, while other tools might not.

Ad Blockers and Cookie Consent

GA4 relies on JavaScript and cookies for tracking, which can be blocked by users’ browsers, ad blockers, or cookie consent settings. Other platforms may have more robust ways of bypassing these blockers.

Event Deduplication

GA4 attempts to deduplicate events when users revisit the same page or trigger the same event multiple times. Other tools may count every single interaction.

Steps to Fix or Minimize Discrepancies

1. Align Time Zones

• Go to your GA4 property settings and ensure the time zone matches the time zone settings in other tools.
• For example, if your Google Ads account is set to Pacific Time, adjust your GA4 settings to match.

2. Standardize Attribution Models

• Review the attribution models being used across tools. In GA4, navigate to Admin > Attribution Settings and compare this with your other tools.
• If needed, create custom reports in GA4 with the same attribution logic as your third-party tools to align data.

3. Use UTM Parameters Consistently

• Ensure your campaign URLs use properly structured UTM parameters. A mismatch in parameters can cause GA4 to misattribute traffic.
• Example: Use utm_source, utm_medium, and utm_campaign in all your marketing URLs.

4. Check Event Implementation

• Verify that all events in GA4 are being tracked correctly. Use the DebugView in GA4 to ensure no events are missed or duplicated.
• Compare event names and configurations to those in other platforms. For instance, a “Purchase” event in GA4 may not align with how your CRM records a sale.

5. Address Cookie Consent Issues

• If you're based in regions with strict privacy laws (like GDPR or CCPA), ensure you’re using a consent management platform (CMP) that integrates with GA4.
• Tools like OneTrust or Cookiebot can help ensure that users who opt out are excluded consistently across platforms.

6. Audit Sampling Issues

• If your GA4 reports are sampled, switch to Explore reports, which often provide unsampled data.
• Alternatively, export data to BigQuery (GA4's native integration) for in-depth, unsampled analysis.

7. Compare Metrics Apples-to-Apples

Different platforms often define metrics differently. For example:

• Users in GA4 may not match Leads in a CRM.
• Session Duration in GA4 stops counting after inactivity, while other tools might calculate it differently.

Align definitions before comparing metrics.

8. Reconcile Conversion Tracking

If you’re running paid campaigns, ensure that conversions are being tracked consistently across GA4 and your ad platforms. This often involves:

• Checking your event tags in Google Tag Manager.
• Ensuring conversion windows (e.g., 7-day or 30-day) match between tools.

9. Monitor Ad Blockers

Use server-side tagging in GA4 to bypass ad blockers. This requires advanced implementation, but it can help capture more accurate data.

10. Use Data Blending for Analysis

Tools like Google Data Studio (now called Looker Studio) allow you to merge data from GA4 and other platforms. While this won’t “fix” discrepancies, it can provide a clearer picture by blending data sources.

Common Scenarios and Quick Fixes

Scenario 1: GA4 Shows Lower Conversions Than Facebook Ads

Fix: Check attribution windows. Facebook often attributes conversions up to 28 days post-click, while GA4 may use shorter windows. Adjust GA4 settings to compare under similar conditions.

Scenario 2: Email Traffic Missing in GA4

Fix: Ensure your email links include UTM parameters. Without them, GA4 might categorize traffic as "Direct."

Scenario 3: Bounce Rate Looks Different

Fix: GA4 replaced the traditional "Bounce Rate" with "Engagement Rate." Compare “Engaged Sessions” in GA4 to bounce metrics in other tools.

Final Thoughts

Data discrepancies can be frustrating, but they’re not unusual. The key is to identify the root cause and address it systematically. By aligning settings, standardizing tracking methods, and reconciling key metrics, you can significantly reduce discrepancies and gain more confidence in your data.

Remember, no tool provides a "perfect" picture. Your job is to interpret the data holistically, focusing on trends and patterns rather than obsessing over exact numbers. After all, data is a guide—not gospel.

For those looking to enhance data accuracy, Trusted Web Eservices offers Google Analytics 4 (GA4) setup services for major e-commerce platforms like BigCommerce, Magento 2, Shopify, Squarespace, Wix, WooCommerce, and WordPress. The GA4 Ecommerce Tracking Setup includes installation, configuration, and testing of essential tracking features, enabling store owners to monitor sales data, customer behavior, and website performance effectively.