What to Look for in a High Quality High School Program: A Parents Guide

As a parent, choosing the right high school for your child can feel overwhelming. There are so many options—public, private, charter, magnet, online—and each promises something different. But if your goal is to set your child up for college success, not all high school programs are created equal. Understanding what defines a high-quality high school program can help you make a confident, informed decision.

One term you may have come across is college preparatory. But what does it really mean—and how do you know if a school that claims to be “college prep” is actually preparing students for college?

Let’s break it down.

What Does “College Preparatory” Actually Mean?

In theory, a college preparatory high school (or "college prep" school) is one that focuses on building the academic foundation, critical thinking skills, and study habits students need to succeed in college. These schools are often rigorous, offering advanced coursework like AP (Advanced Placement) or IB (International Baccalaureate) classes, as well as strong advising systems to guide students through the college admissions process.

But here's the truth: “college preparatory” is a broad term. Nearly any school can claim the label. So, rather than just going by the name, it’s important to dig deeper into what the school actually offers.

Key Features of a True College Preparatory Program

When evaluating a high school, keep an eye out for these signs that a program truly lives up to its college preparatory reputation:

1. Rigorous Academic Curriculum

Look for schools that challenge students. That doesn’t mean the school should overwhelm them, but it should encourage growth and push students to expand their thinking. Honors, AP, or IB classes are great indicators of academic rigor. Even better? A curriculum that balances challenge with support.

2. College Counseling and Support Services

A strong college prep program includes dedicated counselors who work closely with students from as early as freshman year. These counselors should help students identify their goals, choose the right classes, prepare for standardized tests, and build strong college applications. If possible, ask how many students each counselor serves—a lower student-to-counselor ratio is ideal.

3. Opportunities for Enrichment

Does the school offer opportunities beyond the classroom—like clubs, academic competitions, internships, summer programs, or research opportunities? A well-rounded education is crucial for college applications and personal growth. Enrichment activities also help students discover interests and passions they can pursue in college and beyond.

4. Track Record of College Acceptance

One of the most telling signs of a good college preparatory program is the success of its graduates. Where do students go after graduation? Do they attend selective colleges? Are they completing college degrees? Schools that publish college acceptance and matriculation data show transparency—and a strong track record is a solid vote of confidence.

What Questions Should You Ask?

When visiting a school or speaking with an admissions representative, don’t hesitate to ask:

• How does your school define “college prep”?

• What percentage of students take AP or IB classes?

• What kind of college counseling is provided—and when does it begin?

• Can you share data about college acceptance rates?

• How does the school support students who are struggling academically?

These questions help separate marketing speak from real substance.

Public vs. Private College Prep Schools

Some public magnet and charter schools offer outstanding college preparatory programs—often tuition-free. At the same time, private schools may offer smaller class sizes and more personalized support. Neither is automatically better. What matters most is whether the specific program meets your child’s academic needs, interests, and learning style.

Is a College Preparatory School Right for Every Student?

Not necessarily. Some students may thrive in a traditional school setting, or even benefit from a trade or vocational program. But for students who are college-bound—and want to attend a four-year university—a strong college preparatory program can make a real difference. It offers both the academic readiness and the confidence students need to transition smoothly into higher education.

Final Thoughts: Your Child, Your Choice

Choosing a high school is a personal decision, and no two students are the same. What’s right for one family may not be the best fit for another. But if college is on the horizon for your child, looking for a school with a real commitment to college preparatory education is a smart move.

Visit schools, talk to teachers and counselors, and trust your instincts. With the right foundation, your child can walk into college not just ready—but prepared to thrive.